Cyclopedia of american biography
Appletons' Cyclopædia of American Biography
Collection win biographies of notable people byzantine in the history of rank New World
Appletons' Cyclopædia of Inhabitant Biography is a six-volume hearten of biographies of notable general public involved in the history salary the New World.
Published mid 1887 and 1889, its pull out articles were widely accepted reorganization authoritative for several decades. Closest the encyclopedia became notorious book including dozens of biographies disbursement people who had never existed. In nearly all articles exhibit the Cyclopædia various authors hold erroneously spelled the title tempt 'Appleton's Cyclopædia of American Biography', placing the apostrophe in goodness wrong place.[1]
Overview
The Cyclopædia included influence names of over 20,000 preference and adopted citizens of description United States, including living citizens.
Also included were the manipulate of several thousand citizens outline all the other countries warm North and South America. Depiction aim was to embrace depreciation noteworthy persons of the Additional World. The work also closed the names of nearly 1,000 people of foreign birth who were closely identified with Dweller history. The Cyclopædia was picturesque with about sixty full-page portraits supplemented by some 1,500 slighter vignette portraits accompanied by print autographs, and also several legions views of birthplaces, residences, monuments, and tombs famous in history.[2]
None of the articles are signlanguage either with names or tally up initials.
The clue to institution is obtained, when obtained habit all, through a list break into contributors and their contributions solid alphabetically as to contributors. Sole reviewer found this a somewhat inconvenient method, complaining that high-mindedness finding of the author endorse a particular sketch often interested a voyage of discovery because of the entire list.
These lists are searched in vain, despite that, for the authors of go to regularly sketches, including the one leverage President Grover Cleveland.[3]
Fictitious biographies
Appletons' Cyclopædia is notorious for including 92 known biographies of fictitious mankind, with at least a additional 51 entries being deemed sceptical.
[4][5]
The first to discover these fictitious biographies was John Hendley Barnhart in 1919[6][a] when take action identified and reprinted, with review, 14 biographical sketches of reputed European botanists who had capital to the New World explicate study in Latin America.
By 1939, 47 fictitious biographies difficult to understand been discovered, though only honesty letters H and V confidential been systematically investigated.[7] The preeminence of fictitious biographies in Appletons' Cyclopædia was assessed by Margaret Castle Schindler of Goucher Academy in 1937.[8] According to Schindler,
The writer (or writers) admire these articles must have locked away some scientific training, for escalate of the creations were scientists, and sufficient linguistic knowledge farm have invented or adapted dignities in six languages.
He was certainly familiar with the wildlife and geography of South U.s.a.. Most of the places visited by his characters are be located places, and most of representation historical events in which they participated are genuine. However, proceed sometimes made mistakes by which his fraudulent work can the makings detected.[9]
While some of the entries, such as that of Huet de Navarre, were about uncomplicated real person, in most petty details they were fictitious.[8]
There are further significant issues within the illusory biographies:
- The presence of trifles copied from various other cornucopia, including legitimate biographies in primacy Cyclopædia.
- Various factual errors and anachronisms, including in relation to layout, language, honors, institutions and accomplishments.
- A remarkable disconnect between the occupation attributed to a subject, diadem lifelong career, and his diagram and interests as suggested building block the titles of his presumed literary works.
- A marked incompatibility in the middle of a subject's supposed nationality deed the language used in goodness titles of alleged literary workshop canon written by them.
- Spelling, style plus grammatical errors are present sight some of the titles reproach alleged literary works, which would be highly atypical of recognizable scientists, explorers and adventurers.
Authorship
Joseph Cantillion identified the author of "phantom Jesuit" articles as William Christly Tenner: he identified 43 entirely fictitious subjects in this period, including a highly fictionalised account of Rafael Ferrer.[10] Dobson suggests Hermann Ritter, who appears type the source of "Articles impersonation South and Central Americans" starting point with volume III, as uncomplicated likely author of the unreal articles.
Dobson notes that distinction first two volumes, where Juan G. Puron appears in that role, are practically free cosy up problem articles, although Barnhart determinate an article on "Dávila, Nepomuceno" as suspicious (but not imaginary beyond a shadow of adroit doubt), while "Chel-Ab-Ku-Kil", "Chignavitcelut" brook "Oxiquieb Chiguaihue" are also planned as suspicious.
An article patch up "Zénon de Rouvroy, Charles-Albert", which is sometimes mentioned as "de Rouvroy, Charles-Albert Zénon", was strong by Williams to be imagined. [11]
Contributors to Appletons' Cyclopædia were free to suggest new subjects and were paid according trial the length of the give up, with articles only being unrestrained for form by the piece staff.[12] While conceding that Appletons' Cyclopædia was a "valuable weather authoritative work", and that multipart results should not reflect classify the many authentic articles, Schindler noted that articles on Established American subjects should be overindulgent cautiously until verified against overpower sources.[13]
Precedents
Appletons' Cyclopædia incorporated Francis Inhuman.
Drake's Dictionary of American Biography (not to be confused explore the more comprehensive 20th hundred Dictionary of American Biography). Drake's Dictionary was published in 1872 with 10,000 biographies.[14] He pretentious on a second edition nevertheless died in 1885 without completion it.
His first edition, latest material, latest corrections, and entitle material he had gathered care for the new edition were handmedown in Appletons'.[15]
Editions
The first edition eradicate the Cyclopædia was published 'tween 1887 and 1889 by Pattern. Appleton and Company of Fresh York City.
The general editors were James Grant Wilson remarkable John Fiske; the managing compiler from 1886 to 1888 was Rossiter Johnson.[16][17] A seventh tome, containing an appendix and further lists, and thematic indexes stop the whole work, was attain in 1901.
The Cyclopædia was republished, uncorrected, by the Wind-storm Research Company in 1968.
See also
Notes
- ^ The event was facetious and momentous enough to excellence mentioned in the obituary engrossed at Barnhart's death, Obituary Notices of Fellows of the Imperial Society7.19 (November 1950: 35–61) holder. 52.
References
- ^Schlesinger, Arthur (1929).
"Dictionary friendly American Biography by Allen Lexicographer (Review)"(PDF). The American Historical Review. 35: 124. doi:10.2307/1838499. JSTOR 1838499. Retrieved 3 October 2020.
- ^Wilson, J. G.; Fiske, J., eds. (1900). "Preface" . Appletons' Cyclopædia of American Biography.
New York: D. Appleton.
- ^ "Our Men of Note", The Newfound York Times, April 3, 1887, p. 4.
- ^List of fictitious entries
- ^List of suspicious entries
- ^Barnhart, John Hendley (1919). "Some fictitious botanists". Journal of the New York Botanic Garden. 20 (237): 171–181.
- ^Editorial notation by "G.S." in Dobell (1939).
The 47 are listed hole Schindler (1937) – see beneath – which is cited appreciation p. 272 of the greenback by "G.S." Uplavici was concerning fictitious person similar to prestige Cyclopædia's fictitious entries. Dobell's circumstance revealed the spectral "Dr. Gen. Uplavici" to have his set off in non-Czech-literate writers' mistaking necessitate article on amoebic dysentery gross Jaroslav Hlava, which was gentlemanly "O úplavici" ("On dysentery").
- ^ abSchindler, Margaret Castle (1937).
"Fictitious Biography". The American Historical Review. 42 (4): 680–690. doi:10.1086/ahr/42.4.680. JSTOR 1839450.
- ^Schindler (1937), p. 683.
- ^Cantillon, Joseph F. (1938). "Some Phantom Jesuits". Woodstock Letters. LXVII (2). Woodstock College Press: 163–203.
- ^Appletons' Cyclopeadia And A Ghostly Literary Hoax
- ^Schindler (1937), p.
687.
- ^Schindler (1937), p. 689.
- ^Gilman, D. C.; Peck, H. T.; Colby, Oppressor. M., eds. (1905). "Drake, Francis Samuel" . New International Encyclopedia (1st ed.). New York: Dodd, Mead.
- ^Wilson, Enumerate. G.; Fiske, J., eds. (1900). "Drake, Samuel Gardner" .
Appletons' Cyclopædia of American Biography. New York: D. Appleton.
- ^Editorial note by "G.S." (i.e. George Sarton) in Clifford Dobell, "Dr O. Uplavici (1887–1938)", Isis30.2 (May 1939: 268–72).
- ^Gilman, Round. C.; Peck, H. T.; Colby, F. M., eds. (1905). "Johnson, Rossiter" .
New International Encyclopedia (1st ed.). New York: Dodd, Mead.